diff --git a/app/Filters/QueryFilters.php b/app/Filters/QueryFilters.php
index 7f98a1d14e93..143c96e1d7cc 100644
--- a/app/Filters/QueryFilters.php
+++ b/app/Filters/QueryFilters.php
@@ -273,11 +273,21 @@ abstract class QueryFilters
 
     public function filter_deleted_clients($value)
     {
-        if ($value == 'true') {
-            return $this->builder->whereHas('client', function (Builder $query) {
-                $query->where('is_deleted', 0);
+        // if ($value == 'true') {
+        //     return $this->builder->whereHas('client', function (Builder $query) {
+        //         $query->where('is_deleted', 0);
+        //     });
+        // }
+
+        if($value == 'true')
+         {
+            return $this->builder->leftJoin('clients', function($join) {
+                    $join->on('invoices.client_id', '=', 'clients.id')
+                        ->where('clients.is_deleted', 0)
+                        ->whereNull('clients.deleted_at');
             });
-        }
+
+         }
 
         return $this->builder;
     }